Divorce Party – Chris considers having another baby with Sheila, so Nick and Emily throw a divorce party to remind him of their unpleasant past. Elsewhere, Marny’s younger sister (Keshia Knight Pulliam) is hired as Gary’s assistant.
Rare Breed – Gary struggles to do it all, balancing his responsibilities as a stay-at-home dad with the demands of his new career. Meanwhile, Nick and Emily have trouble locating a toy that makes noise while they are trying to sleep; and Chris and Shelia are concerned after Ernie is held back in playgroup.
Gary’s Idea – Gary thinks up a business idea that will get him back in the working world, but it doesn’t exactly meet with Marny’s approval. Meanwhile, Chris tries to get out of a slump in his personal life by taking up a new hobby; and Nick’s date night with Emily turns weird when they arrive home to find Chris in a compromising position.
The Will – Gary and Marny have a near-death experience, prompting them to choose guardians for their kids. Meanwhile, Chris is jealous of Ernie’s new male nanny.
Me Time – Marny seeks alone time after the pressures of her job and family start to wear on her. Meanwhile, Chris suggests a trivia night, but Nick and Sheila are too competitive for the rest of the group.
Marny’s Dad – Gary tries to earn respect from Marny’s disapproving father. Meanwhile, Chris and Sheila go on a date, prompting Nick and Emily to go into matchmaking mode.
First Word – The guys wax nostalgic about the past: Chris and Nick disagree on who met Sheila first; and Gary remembers life before becoming a stay-at-home dad. Meanwhile, Chris and Sheila wait for Ernie to say his first word.
Christmas – Gary and Marny try to spice up their relationship with help from Nick and Emily. Meanwhile, Chris and Sheila can’t agree on who should keep their engagement ring.
Thanksgiving – Chris and Sheila decide to host Thanksgiving dinner together, with Sheila cooking a traditional meal in an attempt to impress Chris’ friends. Meanwhile, Gary spends Thanksgiving waiting in line to buy a TV.
First Birthday – Chris rings in Ernie’s first birthday in unconventional style; Gary and Marny try to lose weight by following a kale-only diet; Sheila deals with her recent breakup.