Executive Producer Steven Rea – Jeff promises to help Skye keep looking for answers about her missing father. Nate convinces Jeff that they need to see this mystery through to its conclusion. The Cult production team prepares to film a live scene that will air online after the show’s season finale, but only the actors know how it will end. Meanwhile, on the inside show, Kelly follows a lead on the whereabouts of her parent’s killer, Henry and tracks him to hidden catacombs. There, Billy ambushes Kelly, and taunts her to kill Henry.
1987 – Stuart tasks Nate with deciphering the copy of Kellian’s manuscript but Cameron remains skeptical that Nate can uncover the answers about the Moon Hill parents. Nate asks Allegra to get a message to Jeff if she makes it out alive. Nate reveals to Stuart that 32 followers disappeared from Moon Hill, and gives Stuart a phone number that he found repeated in the manuscript’s code. Jeff and Skye remain in hiding from the True Believers, now that Stuart knows that they know his true identity. Meanwhile, on the inside show, Billy has tracked Henry, the killer of Kelly and Meadow’s parents, and holds him captive. Kelly begins to unravel emotionally as she wrestles with unresolved feeling about her parents’ murders.
Flip the Script – A mysterious surveillance room is uncovered. Meanwhile, Kelly accompanies Meadow to therapy.
The Prophecy of St. Clare – Skye consoles an actress on the “Cult” TV show. Meanwhile, Billy nears his breaking point.
Off to See the Wizard – Skye infiltrates a meeting of new initiates to the True Believers.
The Devil You Know – Stuart invites Roger to a weekend getaway. Meanwhile, Skye discusses the past with her mom over lunch.
Suffer the Children – E.J. aids Jeff and Skye’s investigation of Sakelik.
The Good Fight – Jeff races to find a drug after Skye falls seriously ill.
The Kiss – Jeff and Skye attend a costume party, where Skye’s drink is spiked with a hallucinogenic drug.
Get With the Program – Jeff tells Skye about Ama, a woman he met on a Cult fan site who claims that her husband is missing after becoming obsessed with the show. When they finally meet her, Jeff notices that she has a Cult notebook that looks eerily like Nate’s notebook. Ama introduces Jeff and Skye to a man who finds and deprograms cult members. EJ locates an IP address on a disk that could bring Jeff and Skye one step closer to finding Nate. Meanwhile, on the television show, Kelly finds Professor Patrick, the man who deprogrammed her, at Billy’s compound.