The Place I Called Home – Corcoran, Morehouse and Freeman join a national effort to hunt down John Wilkes Booth. Meanwhile, chaos continues in New York as Tammany Hall finds an unlikely successor to lead.
Beautiful Dreamer – With news of Lincoln’s assassination stunning the nation, Corcoran tries to evade retaliation from Tammany Hall fixer “Wild Bill” Eustace. Meanwhile, Eva’s freedom hangs in the balance.
Good Heart and Willing Hand – Corcoran goes up against Tammany Hall; Matthew Freeman reaches his breaking point; Elizabeth Morehouse spirals further into addiction; Eva’s murder trial begins.
The Fine Ould Irish Gintleman – Corcoran solicits coppers to uncover the truth about Gen. Donovan’s outpost in Five Points. Meanwhile, Robert Morehouse’s marriage endangers his business; and the Freemans confront bigots at home.
Think Gently of the Erring – Corcoran returns to the precinct and discovers that a new investigation has landed a close friend in chains. Meanwhile, Freeman joins forces with Morehouse to help the city.
Ashes Denote That Fire Was – Corcoran suffers a shocking loss; Freeman goes beyond his role as a doctor to help fight the illness that is sweeping through Five Points; and Morehouse fights to ensure that part of his tumultuous past remains hidden.
The Hope Too Bright to Last – Corcoran hits a dead end in his investigation; Freeman fights to contain the outbreak of a mysterious illness in Five Points; Elizabeth tries to help with Morehouse’s business; and Donovan connives with Eva Heissen.
To One Shortly to Die – The Freemans welcome a loved one back into their home; Eva and Ellen struggle to keep their shared secrets hidden; Corcoran is forced to work with an unlikely partner to investigate a murder.
A Morning Song – A local safe haven is seized by one of the most dangerous men in Five Points as coppers and civilians alike race to restore order to the Sixth Ward. Meanwhile, Maguire settles a score.
I Defy Thee to Forget – The search for a cop killer is derailed when Annie Reilly creates a rift in the Corcoran home. Meanwhile, Eva discovers an unlikely ally in Donovan; Elizabeth soothes her troubled conscience by helping the Freemans; and Maguire crosses paths with some of his old friends.